Myth destroyed: printing money must create inflation

introduction

London ranks ninth within the UBS Global Real Estate Bubble Index for residential real estateAs in lots of other countries, real estate prices in Great Britain reached an all-time high in 2020A world pandemic with sudden mass unemployment must have forced British residents to sell their homes, however the Short-time work guidelines, Stamp duty holidayand record low rates of interest have greater than offset this.

A two-bedroom flat of 93 square metres in a fancy area like Hampstead in north-west London costs around £1.5 million. Rent is around £3,000 a month, which equates to a paltry gross yield of two.4 per cent. After maintenance and tax, it’s more like 1.7 per cent. Many of the homes on this area are over 100 years old and wish numerous love.

While such a low yield could seem unattractive to rental property owners, it was significantly worse for a lot of the last decade when financing costs were higher than rental yields. Buyers were simply betting on price appreciation and were willing to simply accept negative money flow over the lifetime of their investment.

Thanks to COVID-19 and the Bank of England (BOE), borrowing costs at the moment are lower than rental income and property investors’ money flow has turn out to be positive. For those considering buying a property for their very own use, paying interest and repayments is now often cheaper than renting. What an odd world.

But buying a flat in areas like Hampstead normally requires at the very least 25% equity, as banks have turn out to be more conservative because the global financial crisis. Even if a prospective buyer has saved several hundred thousand kilos for a deposit, they are going to still find yourself having to pay back the £1.1 million loan. Before tax, that is almost double the cash that should be earned.

Some potential buyers actively bet on inflation to scale back the debt burden over time. The theory is that every one the monetary and financial policy of the last decade will result in higher inflation. Income and real asset valuations should rise with inflation, but the quantity of credit stays the identical and erodes in real terms.

Is this just wishful considering on the a part of real estate speculators or is the idea supported by the info?

Central banks’ balance sheet expansion

Central banks are sometimes credited with saving the world with their aggressive monetary stimulus throughout the 2008 global financial crisis. But the crisis happened greater than a decade ago and the fundamental measures are still in place. Central banks’ balance sheets proceed to grow. In countries like Germany, this continuous money printing is viewed with sheer horror, because it is related to the hyperinflation of the Weimar Republic within the Nineteen Twenties.

With the COVID-19 crisis, central banks have accelerated their money printing even further. The US Federal Reserve’s balance sheet has exceeded the $7 trillion markcomparable to the The 7 trillion euros of the European Central Bank (ECB)Central banks appear to have chained themselves to the general public markets and are forced to intervene each time stock prices fall significantly.

The unnatural consequences of this behavior have gotten increasingly obvious. The Bank of Japan (BOJ), for instance, owns greater than 75 percent of the exchange-traded funds (ETFs) domiciled there.

Central banks’ balance sheet expansion

Money supply

There are different yardsticks for measuring the cash supply. M1 represents all physical money in circulation, each in money and in checking accounts, and has been on a downward trend within the US, Europe, the UK and Japan because the Eighties.

None of the monetary policy stimulus measures implemented since 2009 have had an impact on money circulation. This is even true for broader monetary measures similar to M2 or M3, which include savings deposits and money market funds.

In 2020, the US government issued COVID-19 stimulus checks, which had a major impact on M1 by hugely increasing the amount of money in circulation. The UK and EU governments responded in another way and didn’t issue direct money payments to their residents, so M1 remained the identical in those countries.

Increase in the cash supply M1

Central bank expansion, money supply and inflation in Japan

Japan offers compelling insights into the connection between central bank balance sheets, money supply and inflation. The Japanese government and central bank have been on the forefront of monetary policy experiments because the collapse of the Japanese economy within the Nineteen Nineties following enormous bubbles in stocks and real estate.

Today, Japan’s economy is combating demographic problems, however the goals of the federal government and the central bank have remained the identical: to create moderate inflation and positive economic growth.

After calculating the rolling 10-year yields of the central bank balance sheet, the cash supply M1 and inflation, we come to 3 observations:

1. The BoJ’s balance sheet total has multiplied since 2008.
2. The central bank’s activities had little impact on the cash supply or inflation.
3. Inflation and money supply are sometimes strongly correlated, but not at all times.

Intuitively, inflation should follow the cash supply. The more cash circulating in an economy, the greater the demand for services and products, which in turn should result in higher prices. However, the economy consists of many interrelated variables and linear models often fail to reflect reality.

Central bank expansion, money supply and inflation: Japan

Central bank expansion, money supply and inflation within the United States

The same three economic variables show the identical increase within the central bank balance sheet within the US as in other markets and only muted effects on money supply and inflation. Moreover, inflation can occur even without significant changes in the cash supply, similar to throughout the oil crisis within the Nineteen Seventies.

Some investors are betting that inflation will follow the rise in money supply in 2020. This is feasible, because the cash supply has been increasing for over a decade, but inflation has been falling steadily over the identical period.

Central Bank Expansion, Money Supply and Inflation: United States

Central bank expansion, money supply and inflation within the United Kingdom

The BOE has time series dating back to well before the Middle Ages. It is a forum for economists and financial data enthusiasts.

The UK data show that between 1947 and 1995 there was a powerful positive correlation between the BoE’s balance sheet, money supply and inflation. But after that, these relationships broke down. Money supply and inflation still moved in lockstep, however the central bank’s activities seemed largely irrelevant.

We aren’t economists and have no idea why these relationships have modified. It might be resulting from the character of central bank activities. Perhaps central bank activities was directly linked to the cash supply, while modern policy is more geared towards influencing financial markets.

Central bank expansion, money supply and inflation: United Kingdom

Further considerations

Similar analyses of the Eurozone reflect the identical trend: central bank printing of cash is basically irrelevant for the cash supply and inflation.

Given their actual mandate to create moderate inflation, the all-powerful central banks seem quite powerless. Or they’re simply battling against forces they can not overcome: namely, negative demographic and productivity growth, which result in low economic growth.

Should investors be concerned about central banks’ massive money printing? Certainly. It has distorted financial markets and driven up prices across all asset classes. But perhaps it can simply result in lower future returns quite than higher inflation.

However, if more direct fiscal or monetary stimulus is implemented on a everlasting basis, investors can have greater cause for concern. Experience shows that this can be a recipe for disaster for renters and owners alike.

Further insights from Nicolas Rabener and the FactorResearch Team, join on your Email newsletter.

If you liked this post, don’t forget to subscribe.

Photo credit: ©Getty Images / M_D_A